The Hot Button of Nurturing
Have you thought about your product or store as a nurturing environment? If not, than thinking about it may open up a whole new marketing venue for you.
It was some time ago when I learned how important the nurturing need is to marketers in even the most common of product categories. I was speaking to a young woman when I developed a new kid's toothpaste for Colgate-Palmolive. Actually we weren't even trying to develop a new kid's toothpaste. We were trying to develop any kind of toothpaste that could make money for Colgate and that their salespeople could sell without a great deal of resistance from retailers or buyers. They were tired of getting beat up by Crest.
The young woman was a receptionist in our office. We had literally hundreds of ideas and concepts pinned to the wall, focusing on taste, therapeutic appeal or anything we could add to the product. She looked at them and said they were cute, but meaningless and insignificant, at least to her. I asked why.
The woman said many of her friends were unwed mothers or first-time mothers. They wanted assurance and reassurance that they were providing the best of care for their children. They wanted a toothpaste that spoke to their needs and to their children's needs in a non-condescending way. So while we were exploring the world of tastes and textures, there was an unmet psychological need just waiting to be fulfilled. There was a whole segment of consumers who wanted to feel good knowing they were doing their job well. We extended the concept and found that most mothers had the same concern. Out of this project came Colgate Jr. (originally named First Brush) and a whole line of oral care products positioned to moms - for their children
Nurturing is about physical growth and emotional growth. Who doesn't smile when the commercial for a child's disposable underpants comes on and the child proudly says, "I did it myself?" It's easy to relate to.
A supermarket can be a nurturing environment also. It's stocked with colors and shapes and forms. A magical place for kids. It's also a space where children learn about the buying experience. Kids have product categories neatly folded in their own area and mom's area -- in the kids minds anyway. Children own the breakfast food category, and in the freezer, the ice cream and frozen novelty category. It's important to know this because by thinking of your store or product in the nurturing sense can lead you to new marketing and advertising opportunities.
But nurturing is not just for kids.
The nurturing response is one of the great pulls in life. Lucky Dog dog food, Band Aids, even Miracle-Gro plant food are sold on the basis of nurturing. Whole industries have sprung up by pushing the nurturing hot button. A big growth sector exists for high-priced dog foods that, for some reason, consumers perceive as better for their pets than massed produced dog foods with funny names. The ads always point out the caring relationship owners have with their pets.
Myself as hero
Relationships are a key component of the nurturing hot button. Seeing mom or dad as hero for choosing the product pushes the hot button. In terms of communications and selling, we can't use a deployment of the classic product-as-hero strategy. Seeing your product as the hero -- just the way most consumer products are promoted -- can actually be a big mistake. The customer is the nurturer or healer for CHOOSING the product -- not your product. Call it the Doctor Syndrome. When one goes to the doctor and gets a penicillin shot, is the penicillin treated as hero? No. It is the doctor who is considered heroic for having the knowledge to prescribe the drug. The successful nurturing approach idealizes the consumer as nurturer or care-giver. When one goes to a nurturing institute like a preschool, we talk about the teachers, not the books they use. The Colgate product worked because mom found the product that appealed to her needs. It was mom who found a way to get her child to brush his or her teeth willingly.
Some nurturing categories and sells are obvious - some are not
The obvious products associated with nurturing include those for birthing, childcare, pet care, cooking and even laundry. Yes, washing clothes carries a ton of emotional hot buttons and nurturing cues. That's why laundry makers add scents to their products. To stretch the market further, we can include plants and garden items, charities and "feel-good" companies. Goodwill Industries is a great example of operating as a "feel-good" company, under the premise of helping poor people. In reality, they are a for-profit business that sells used goods. But they use the nurturing appeal so well, people don't even question that Goodwill Industry's sole purpose is to nurture poor people.
Use the nurturing approach in your offerings
Comfort foods like potatoes and pasta are a great part of the nurturing. Imagine if a manufacturer could come up with a positioning for green beans and lettuce that would get kids to eat more. It's not impossible. Put a cartoony logo on the the product and add something kids like, for instance pasta. How about adding some fun and nutrition in pot pies. It's a category bereft of fun. But it takes more than fun. For mom to be hero the foods must contain some elements of health. Fisher Boy had major problems when they tried to create a kids product. They came up with a cute name and package, but the product was extended with French Fries -- not on any consumer's healthy 100 list. Lunchables, of course has done a great job, by attracting kids with their candy, but putting in healthy meats and cheeses. It's important to give mom some kind of visual cue that the product is made for kids. Try cross-marketing your product with the school supply section. Moms know the product is as for kids and you get healthy play in another section of the store.
Girl Scout Cookies -- a nurturing experience or merchandising tool?
When you talk about the epitome of marketing under the hot button of nurturing you're talking about Girl Scout cookies. The entire concept is built on the nurturing response. When you buy a box of cookies, you think you're contributing to the emotional growth of a young girl. The Girl Scout cookie drive is a marketing phenomenon. Stores let the girls stand in front of a supermarket and sell, even if it negatively impacts on the stores own cookie sales. We, and the store's PR department, feel that we are enriching the kids' hearts and minds. The store bathes under the halo of doing a good deed, which does not go unnoticed by the public. Try doing the same thing with fundraising projects for a local school or organization. Create a whole fundraising section -- they are more than enough suppliers out there to keep you well stocked. It will bring in good will and profits.
.